December 15, 2016
Bad Santa (2003)
Bad Santa is one of my favourite Christmas movies. On a superficial level it is a gross-out comedy packed with swearing, drinking, poor behaviour, and criminal activity. Everything is taken to excess, particularly anything to do with Willie. He drinks alcohol until he has to throw up in an alleyway. He has a penchant for anal sex with large women. When dressed as Santa Claus he swears at and verbally abuses the very children he is supposed to be entertaining. At one point he is so drunk he urinates in his Santa suit.
I imagine a lot of people tried Bad Santa and hated it, and that's fair enough: the film's roughest elements are clearly more than a lot of people will find entertaining. That said, I personally adore the film because underneath that superficial layer of poor behaviour there is a heartwarming story about a bad man learning to become a better person.
The film works as well as it does partly because the cast commit to it so well. Billy Bob Thornton is pitch-perfect as Willie, managing to simultaneously engage in terrible behaviour while also convincing the audience of the better, nicer man inside just struggling to get out. It is a nice touch that he never really does emerge as a properly decent human being; even in his best moments he is still rough as all hell.
Tony Cox and Lauren Tom are great as Marcus and Lois, Willie's married couple accomplices whose obsession with their ill-gotten loots surpasses any other considerations. They present a strong contrast to Willie as the film goes on. He is a bad person who struggles to be good. They are simply bad people. The late John Ritter creates the most wonderfully awkward of characters in the shopping centre manager, who fusses over the correct term for little people so much that he inadvertently sounds more offensive than if he'd simply insulted them. This was his final film role. Bernie Mac is head-scratchingly weird as the centre's security chief, who eats four mangoes at a time at his desk and seems obsessed with chain-smoking, drinking Metamucil and having pedicures. As the naive child that latches leech-like onto Thornton's Santa (his name would spoil a great joke) Brett Kelly is hilarious. Lauren Graham is under-used as Willie's new girlfriend Sue, but effective when the film allows her to be.
The bleak, mean-spirited humour is great. The film's director, Terry Zwigoff, has a well-rehearsed ability to be off-kilter and perverse, primarily through his exceptional 1994 documentary Crumb and his 2001 cult hit Ghost World. Taste is broadly subjective, and comedy particularly so, but for people who like a film that takes an edge and makes fun of unpleasant situations and people Bad Santa is absolutely one of the best ones.
And underneath it all, there's that proper Christmas story. Willie hates everyone, but cannot help but start caring about this stupid, weirdly obsessive child. It gives him a moral centre that he never used to have. It makes him finally begin doing the right things in life - often in the wrong way, but to an extent it's the thought that counts. It may be mean, gross and wildly offensive to many, but Bad Santa is ultimately about a Grinch's heart growing two sizes. It is, as I've said above, one of my absolute favourite movies for the festive season: it hurls abuse at Christmas and kind of celebrates it too.