July 10, 2012
Judging the New 52 #3: Legion of Super-Heroes
It's very good, but it's also almost impenetrable. I've read 10 issues and I can recognise three of the regular cast: Brainiac 5, Chameleon Boy and Mon-El. Others I may recognise them on the page, or know the name, but I'm unlikely to know both at the same time. It's also a very serialised title, which is an oddity in an industry geared towards broadly self-contained multi-part stories (what we call "writing for the trade"). I think it's a very enjoyable comic book, and if you've ever had an interest in the Legion you should check it out, but it's a comic you need to be reading for the long haul to give yourself time to get immersed in its characters and storylines. The first trade paperback is out rather cheaply ($19.95 in Australia), and is the best way to start.
So how does such a 'hard-core' comic fare in terms of sales? Pretty much as you might expect.
They're clearly very similar, although the one thing I will note is that it took eight issues for the New 52 edition to bottom out, and 16 issues for the Pre-52 edition to do the same. I suspect the bottom line is that there are about 20,000 hard-core Legion fans who are going to purchase this book rain or shine, and another 25,000 comic book readers who are intrigued by the title but simply can't engage with it before losing interest.
I think there's huge sales potential in Legion of Super-Heroes. It has a strong history and legacy, a rich and varied set of characters (except in their names - all Something Lad or Whatever Girl), and a combination of far future space opera and superheroics. It needs a much tighter introduction than the most recent reboot, however, and a real push from DC's marketing people to get people reading it again.