November 21, 2014
The events that led to this documentary being produced - the violent death of a Seaworld trainer - could easily inspire something quite sensationalistic and tacky. It is testament to Cowperthwaite's skills as a filmmaker that it never takes this route. It is oftentimes confronting, and in some scenes quite violent and brutal, but it never loses sight of what it is aimed to do, and it succeeds admirably in its goals. This is not simply a worthwhile and informative documentary - it is a necessary one.
It's a wonderfully even-handed documentary. It is narrated, almost in chorus, by a series of former Seaworld trainers who for one reason or another have left the company. It is primarily through them that we hear of Tilikum's life, his extraordinary history of abuse, and the factors that likely led to the death of trainer Dawn Brancheau. They are almost universally very sorry for their part in Seaworld's abuse of its animals. The film takes care not to demonise these people: they all made mistakes, and all participated in something terrible, but each of them comes across as older, much wiser and extraordinarily regretful for their youthful naivete.
Similarly, Tilikum is never portrayed as anything but an innocent victim: he is a wild animal, and has been treated horribly over more than 20 years of captivity. Despite his killing three people he is never portrayed as a violent killer or an innately evil animal.
Seaworld itself, however, is slowly and categorically demolished by this film. It begins subtly, with obvious evidence that the company acted more in the interests in its financial bottom line than in the welfare of its animal performers. Then, as the film goes on, it becomes clear the company cares more about money than the welfare of its trainers as well. By the film's conclusion it has formed a logical, well-researched and utterly savage indictment of Seaworld - and indeed in similar parks around the world where killer whales and dolphins are forced to perform in this manner. It's a horrible, loathsome situation.
This film reminded me a great deal of Project Nim, another film in which naivete and ignorance lead to the mistreatment of an innocent animal and a grave risk to human lives. That these things go on is terrible. That these filmmakers take the time and immense talent to tell us these stories should be commended, and we should all be watching them. It's painful, and oftentimes deeply upsetting, but we need to know this happens.